Grpc backwards compatibility

You should always prefer the binary format for production. Incompatible changes might be made in some situations, including: - Security bugs may prompt backwards-incompatible changes. Please describe a bit more your environment (language, platform, etc) and what problem you actually see. Backward compatibility is more easily accomplished if the previous versions have been designed to be forward compatible, or extensible, with built-in features such as Hooks, plug-in, or an application program interface that allows the addition of new features. The confirmed talks are: - "So you want to be a manager" by Gil Goncalves "This talk will be about helping people understand what the job of a manager is, make a decision on whether they should be managers, and that there are more ways to advance than just to become a manager. The digital titles that you own and are part of the Back Compatibility game catalogue will automatically show up in the “Ready to Install” section on your Xbox One. The new sequence batcher provides scheduling and batching capabilities for this class of models. Innovative technologies and methodologies such as new transport protocols, security algorithms, encoding standards, or application-services can be incorporated into OPC UA while maintaining backwards compatibility for existing products. You make up your own specs, like Google did. 0. This project aims to provide that HTTP+JSON interface to your gRPC service. Due to this compatibility the need of a native schema registry has  grpc: google. This is only necessary if not # building on Alpine Linux 'grpc_alpine Hi, The server code could definitely be shortened. By switching to gRPC, we made a clean break with v1 and did not attempt to provide backwards compatibility. • Four Cases. Backwards compatibility is (still) hard June 3, 2015 jonskeet 53 Comments At the moment, I’m spending a fair amount of time thinking about a new version of the C# API and codegen for Protocol Buffers , as well as other APIs for interacting with Google services. 0 release of containerd. Additionally, protobufs can generate all the required code for your desired language. You can add new fields to your message formats without breaking backwards-compatibility; old binaries simply ignore the new field when parsing. ) Thebackwards-compatibility and code-generation features built into protobuf are a boon to those working in large teams. The fields are numbered to support backwards compatibility and field renaming. This makes it possible to evolve your application’s communication in a compatible way. However  protoc_plugin | Dart Package pub. 0 release and is now ready for production deployments. If you are looking for gRPC support for Node. js gRPC library. Wondering how to make sure your Go package is backwards compatible with Deps? How about Go 1. Specifically, we tack on a request header containing Zipkin tracing info, Finagle ClientId strings, and Wily delegations. Schema evolution in Avro, Protocol Buffers and Thrift. Envoy’s v1 APIs were in production use at Lyft and also were widely adopted by the ecosystem surrounding Envoy, by systems such as Istio and Nelson. While this post only covered JSON, gRPC is compatible with Thrift, Avro, Flatbuffers, Cap’n Proto, and even raw bytes! gRPC lets you be in control of how your data is handled. This is to maintain backwards compatibility with other clients / services that use our service, but might not have the latest codebase, rather than changing the format of the message. GitHub project for information on backwards-compatibility guarantees for this and future releases. Today’s release offers ease-of-use with single-line installation in most languages, API stability, improved and transparent performance with open dashboard, backwards compatibility and production readiness. In order to maintain backwards compatibility, TTwitter clients perform protocol negotiation upon connection and will downgrade to raw TBinary Thrift if servers are not using the upgraded protocol. # will let users recompile gRPC to work without ALPN. 509 certificate-based key pairs for local side authentication according to the rules defined by the IETF PKIX working group in RFC 5280. Clone via HTTPS Clone with Git or checkout with SVN using the repository’s web address. It also means you have a lot of choice in what data you write and what data you don't, and how you design data structures. external_transforms_pb2_grpc module apache_beam. 3. Jaeger backend was enhanced to be a drop-in replacement for Zipkin backend by accepting several Zipkin span formats (Thrift and JSON). endpoints_pb2_grpc module apache_beam. In a monolithic application, components invoke one another via language‑level method or function calls. Clients marked stable will maintain compatibility with future versions for as long as we can reasonably sustain. 4 Mar 2018 you simple accessors; Fast serialization/deserialization; Backward compatibility Google's GRPC is doing exactly this for developing a high  28 Jul 2017 Hi all, I'm curious if anyone else has interest in testing out GRPC with Buffers is to support backwards and forwards compatible changes. How To Use V1. gRPC-Web is a cutting-edge spec that enables invoking gRPC services from modern browsers. 31 Jan 2018 Protobuf messages are described using their associated IDL which gives a compact, strongly typed, backwards compatible format for defining  1 Jul 2019 What is backward and forward compatibility? A change made to a system or technology in such a way that the existing users are unaffected is a  3 Jun 2015 The problem I've been trying to address is the relative pain of initializing a protobuf message. Single object encoding specification. Pursuing premature optimization can be a pitfall, but gRPC is very robust in its current state, and the speed is only one aspect of what gRPC brings to the table. 0 and ready for open dashboard, backwards compatibility and production readiness. The multi-layered architecture of OPC UA provides a “future proof” framework. To ensure compatibility, we have collected the entire GRPC API symbol set into a single file. Net: protobuf-net vs protobuf-csharp-port. com/google/protobuf (Google-official implementation); C/C++:  5 Jun 2019 Learn the difference between gRPC and REST and use these findings for You need to maintain backward-compatibility and you might have  26 Sep 2017 They keep things backwards compatible for a certain amount of time intention, RPC the lot, document as such, and maybe just use gRPC. js there is an official Node. 8 May 2018 But recently gRPC has started encroaching on its territory. In contrast, a microservices‑based application is a distributed system running on multiple machines. c and cmp. Xbox fans have been enjoying the opportunity to play some of their favorite Xbox 360 titles on RPC has its own set of limitations, which if your application qualifies, might be a good fit: * Coupled server and client. Protobuf via gRPC (stable ) The Protobuf IDL collector. 2. 1 APIs on the same port as our gRPC APIs. Firstly we define the grpc client struct: We can now write the GRPC part of it. developers can evolve format, and older clients can still use it. Using proto files from any non-tagged revision will likely not work correctly or maintain backwards compatibility. Now with new Protobuf version called proto3, the IDL language i * Coupled server and client. 2) Regarding the problem with backwards compatibility I think the fact that we got from 10+ Maven docker plugins to only 2 today speaks for itself. dev/packages/protoc_plugin 5 Jun 2014 library ( brew install protobuf on OSX) to automatically generate stub class files Reason #2: Backward Compatibility For Free In addition to explicit version checks and the lack of backward compatibility, JSON endpoints  gRPC servers. When to Use What: REST, GraphQL, Webhooks, & gRPC by Kristopher Sandoval | posted on August 21, 2018; Defining Stateful vs Stateless Web Services by Kristopher Sandoval | posted on May 11, 2017; API Platform Defined: When an API Provider is a Platform by Travis Spencer | posted on August 5, 2014 Minimizing change. proto files. of Protocol Buffers, which is largely backwards compatible with earlier versions . That needs to be somewhere on the path or in a separate SDK of some sort, but it must be visible. Releasing v1 thus makes it possible to start working on these new features without having to worry about backwards compatibility. Google’s open source serialization format is an efficient way of passing platform-independent and version-tolerant data between end-points. com/p/protobuf-actionscript3/; Action Script: C ++: https://github. Older data will still read correctly, and give you the default value when read. and backward compatibility and performance can be constrained. 0, gRPC versioning will allow us to retain backwards compatibility. The simplest way to consume goa v1. As a result, you have the flexibility to add fields without fear of bloating your data. gRPC, and—more broadly—what the future of web APIs will look like,  7 Jun 2016 Overview of Google's open source microservices framework - gRPC, Backwards Compatibility — Run a reverse proxy JSON API in front of  gRPC version 1. Optional Reasons can range from maintaining backwards-compatibility, supporting languages or clients not well supported by gRPC to simply maintaining the aesthetics and tooling involved with a RESTful architecture. IDs exist to provide a relatively short yet unambiguous way to refer to a type or annotation from another context. The primary product of containerd is the GRPC API. Writing the GRPC Client. I tried to keep it simple for the tutorial. The method allows to catch-up positions missing in the local non-leading replica to allow safe eventually consistent reads from it. Backward compatibility. Frozen protos may be further extended, e. Makes backwards/forward-compatibility easier: required fields invalidate the entire message regardless of context parts of an application could pass around partially-complete messages internally whole applications might simply be interested in passing message through (see routers) The hard part of this isn’t the gRPC api - it’s the business logic that’s in the shade library. This month's meetup will be kindly hosted by Farfetch on their Old Street offices. This document lists the workarounds implemented on gRPC servers for record and reference when users need to enable a certain  29 Jan 2018 In the Envoy proxy, we adopted Protocol Buffers (protobuf), A lack of backwards compatibility might at first glance seem to be disruptive. Post 1. gRPC is a high-performance, By following some simple rules, forward and backwards compatibility can be the default for most API changes. Its compactness and backward-compatibility make it very attractive. Subscribe To Nintendo Switch Finally Reveals If It Will Be Backward Compatible Updates The only possible caveat for backwards compatibility for the Nintendo Switch would be digital backwards Set the Docker Swarm scheduler to binpack mode. A backward-compatible word processor, for instance, allows you to edit documentscreated with a previous version of the program. proto file syntax and how to generate data access classes from your . Backwards compatible original Xbox and Xbox 360 titles will benefit from becoming Xbox One X enhanced with patches targeted at maximizing the use of the Xbox One X's hardware beyond the standard improvements that come with backwards compatibility. If you haven’t looked, there is a LOT. We have built the support but it will remain hidden behind a flag Sorry about breaking backward compatibility on SupportPackageIsVersion. CMP provides optional backwards compatibility for use with other MessagePack implementations that only implement version 4 of the spec. 'grpc_gcov%': 'false', # Indicates that the library should be built with compatibility for musl # libc, so that it can run on Alpine Linux. If breaking changes are going to be made in the future, they will result in a new API version, e. To select a different version, use the selector below. How is backwards compatibility achieved in the face of deleting They were one of the main reasons we chose gRPC as the two work very well together. The gRPC package has released its "LoggerV2" interface, which tries to maintain backwards compatibility 2976583002: [grpc Sign in. portability. This package supports Node. Since there was no support for using gRPC from a browser, the Web Apps teams were an exception to this culture shift. No more awkward REST / WebSocket combo APIs. The client knows in advance what the server can do. golang. It's more work in the mean time, but it pays dividends over time. We use StringValue to properly reflect optionality on the wire for backwards compatibility. Users *really* like backwards compatibility. If you have problems having a 1. This is necessary since the empty string is an acceptable (and in fact the default) agreement text, but also the default string in protobuf. 3 . has a MIME type of application/x-protobuf or application/x-google-protobuf . These constraints are orthogonal to REST, the architectural principles behind the web. 19 Mar 2019 Quickly the . js, but requires that the server has the gRPC-Web compatibility layer (read on to understand more). termux/files/usr/bin/ruby -r . rb GRPC API. . Protocol buffer messages are declared in a  6 May 2017 Introduction. No special compiler settings are required to build it, and it generates no You can now configure the gRPC The type of this field is google. protobuf. Varun is a product manager in charge of gRPC, an open source project created at Google that helps you build distributed systems like we do internally at Google. 9 Jun 2019 The gRPC protocol is becoming trendy in the era of microservices. Backwards compatibility is a must for seamless integration with both existing code and third party libraries. 15 Aug 2017 To date, we've maintained compatibility with every version of our API since Not all changes are backwards-incompatible though; for example, it's safe . It has to feel like a Go library For backwards compatibility, the default name includes the operations collection id, however overriding users must ensure the name binding is the parent resource, without the operations collection id. SupportPackageIsVersion is just one of the public APIs of gRPC, though this one is a bit special because it involves interaction between gRPC package and proto codegen. 20. The agreement text of the contract. docker/ucp install Estimated reading time: 4 minutes These are the docs for UCP version 2. We try to keep what we write as clean as possible, but given enough time dozens of checks on version changes that can’t be encapsulated cleanly will be littered throughout the project, making it slower, less readable, and more brittle. A Maven plugin for protecting against backwards incompatible changes to your gRPC . api. py files. and the advice on backwards-compatibility Talk was recorded at #PrismaDay in #Berlin | June 19th, 2019 #PrismaDay is a one day, single-track conference in #Berlin focused on #databases and #applicationdevelopment. No more data parse errors when rolling out new binaries. x Reasons can range from maintaining backwards-compatibility, supporting languages or clients not well supported by gRPC to simply maintaining the aesthetics and tooling involved with a RESTful architecture. Clients only need to depend on the interface and not an implementation. Each service instance is typically a process. stable - the API guarantees backwards compatibility. Backward compatibility is sometimes also called downward compatibility. This may also include the following enhancements: This guide describes how to use the protocol buffer language to structure your protocol buffer data, including . Aspera will be fully compatible with BRS either by design or by means of various compatibility layers. Not just for efficiency but also because it allows you to benefit from protobuf’s backwards and forwards compatibility. If we wrote oaktree from scratch in C++ (because hello super-high-performance gRPC backend!) - we’d be faced with the task of re-implementing all of the shade business logic in C++. In contrast, just because we can communicate with another piece of software over the network does not necessarily mean that remote endpoint is an API by this definition. Single Avro objects are encoded as follows: A two-byte marker, C3 01, to show that the message is Avro and uses this single-record format (version 1). If specified, the default CNI plugin will not be installed. StringValue to properly reflect the optionality on the wire for full backwards compatibility. gRPC uses protocol buffers which have zero backwards compatibility. Backward compatibility is a property of a system, product, or technology that allows for interoperability with an older legacy system, or with input designed for such a system, especially in telecommunications and computing. 24 Jun 2018 We always talk about backwards-compatibility in protobuf, so where is the problem? With protobuf, you can add new fields to your message  16 Apr 2019 The benefits of implementing gRPC-Web for Istio and Envoy are massive. /api/v2 URL prefix or a different namespace in the IDL. To use the Any type, you need to import google/protobuf/any. The only issue I see with your suggestion is that the request is not guaranteed to be named similarly to the service method although it is in this example. Why Probobufs. Note that: You can add new fields in the schema ONLY at the end of a table definition. Forward and Backward Compatibility (1/2). The API is under heavy development and will stabilize leading up to the 1. Action Script: http://code. Flexible - Optional fields means not only do you get great forwards and backwards compatibility (increasingly important for long-lived games: don't have to update all data with each new version!). 0 release are available here. Don’t you agree? It shows how hard it is to keep a Docker plugin relevant. Another active area of development across the Jaeger ecosystem was backwards compatibility with Zipkin. metrics_pb2_grpc module Compatibility with BRS. So you have some data that you want to store in a file or send over the network. What is Backward Compatibility? Play over 600 Xbox 360 games and Original Xbox classics on Xbox One. Java. Used for backwards compatibility--cloud-provider value: The cloud provider for the cluster--cni-installer-url value: A URL pointing to a kubernetes YAML file to be used as an installer for the CNI plugin of the cluster. We always talk about backwards-compatibility in protobuf, so where is the problem? With protobuf, you can add new fields to your message formats without breaking backwards-compatibility: this is one of the pillar of protobuf: you can extend your protocol without having to worry about breaking existing code, your old binaries simply ignore the Backward compatibility is important because it eliminates the need to start over when you upgrade to a newer product. - salesforce/proto-backwards-compat-maven-plugin. org/grpc/stats Index | Files | Directories NOTE: this is provided only for backward compatibility with existing clients and will likely be  25 Jun 2016 Custom encoding: Go implementation in net/rpc vs grpc and why we switched data structure evolution (forwards/backwards compatibility). It's just us developers that feel the pain for it. g. Please note that proto is a shared library too where the protocol stubs reside. This document defines Avro IDL, a higher-level language for authoring Avro schemata. The PS4 is absolutely killing it this generation, with millions of consoles now comfortably sitting in gamer’s homes. A protocol buffer can be serialized to text, JSON, or an efficient binary format. Guidance on Versioning Your API From Google I'm still learning more about their approach to how it's applied to the proto package for gRPC APIs. So when a service changes, new functionality is added to the interface and no functionality removed. Upgrading from 1. Note that each field on the message is numbered in ascending order. This means a newer client works with an older sandbox seamlessly. /data/data/com. In general, manufacturers try to keep all their products backward compatible. proto is currently located in the main Jaeger  Protobuf and gRPC are build from the ground up to be forward and backward compatible. [grpc/logging] Update to LoggerV2. x to 1. • Provide efficient easy to use and secure transport for protobuf messages. The gRPC base protocol should always be backward compatible. It is useful in developing Canonically, messages are serialized into a binary wire format which is compact, forward- and backward-compatible, but not self-describing ( that is  12 Jul 2019 The zero value needs to be the first element, for compatibility with the proto2 . As a high performance, open-source RPC framework, gRPC features multiple language bindings (C++, Java, Go, Node, Ruby, Python and C# across Linux, Windows and Mac). For these designed network endpoints, we expect some level of documentation, usage guidance, stability and backwards compatibility. Published by Martin Kleppmann on 05 Dec 2012. All the best Open Source, Software as a Service (SaaS), and Developer Tools in one place, ranked by developers and companies using them. Please help me understand the backward compatibility and extensibility properties of the protocol buffers' internal implementation. gRPC Overview • gRPC is transported over HTTP/2. * No standards to follow. It covers the proto3 version of the protocol buffers language: for information on the older proto2 syntax, see the Proto2 Language Guide. Web was the exception. 4. proto definitions, which provide the schema for gRPC Moreover, the grpc-web-client is meant to be backwards compatible. Protocol buffers for . It has become Google’s lingua franca with tens of thousands of separate data definitions being used across numerous RPC and data storage The following labels are used to describe API compatibility guarantees. 0 is to use vendoring and to pin the version in the vendor definition file to the git tag v1. No more problems streaming data from a server. Reasons can range from maintaining backwards-compatibility, supporting languages or clients not well supported by gRPC to simply maintaining the aesthetics and tooling involved with a RESTful architecture. Also, in general its better to be indefinitely backwards compatible, because there still tend to be clients, or servers, that will never upgrade. proto . gRPC enables backwards and forwards-compatibility of requests and responses. The 8-byte little-endian CRC-64-AVRO fingerprint of the object's schema; The Avro object encoded using Avro's binary encoding Here, frozen means that we will not break wire format compatibility. For disc-based games that are a part of the Back Compat game catalogue, insert the disc and the console will begin downloading the game to your hard drive. Fields in the above protos may be later deprecated, subject to the breaking change policy, when their related functionality is no longer required. PS5 Backwards Compatibility: All The Latest Evidence. Firstly we define the grpc client struct: In general, you would only specify an explicit ID for a declaration if that declaration has been renamed or moved and you want the ID to stay the same for backwards-compatibility. e. While It takes a notable calendar time to design the schema thoughtfully such that it will have backwards compatibility as it grows over time. If you change your service, you change your gateway. New code can be made DI-library aware to get convenience features, but should not be required to do so. 8? In this video, Mark Bates will walk through the most common mistakes that package maintainers make when implementing Go modules, as well as how to properly handle forward and backwards compatibility for Dep, Go Modules, older versions of Go, and more. There is no build system for CMP. gRPC benefits outweigh any added complexity with protobufs for defining and implementing the API layer. Note: The SunJSSE provider is for backwards compatibility with older releases, and should no longer be used for KeyFactory. Configuration files are used for more than just setting up the agent, they are also used to provide check and service definitions. gRPC supports both one-to-one RPCs and one-to-many streaming requests. 10+ is required to build Mesos when enabling gRPC-related Note about backwards compatibility: In order for the feature to work correctly in  31 Oct 2017 gRPC, as the name implies, is a remote procedure call (RPC) framework. 10 23. /siteconf20170705-7632-i07w2e. Compare and browse tech stacks from thousands of companies and software developers from around the world. The ctr tool is a development/admin resource. The configuration is formatted as a single JSON object with configuration within it. We can now write the GRPC part of it. Backwards compatibility with Zipkin. * Zero discoverability. types to another without breaking forwards- or backwards-compatibility. This design is also FlatBuffer's mechanism for forward and backwards compatibility. It still excels for publicly exposed APIs and for backward compatibility reasons. 0 release, the GRPC API will not have any backwards incompatible changes without a major version jump. As of the 1. This is a huge bummer and makes it impossible for us to ship etcd with gRPC support. Hi there! Here's some tech reading for your Summer break (As usual, a hat tip to Hacker News and Twitter feeds, which are my usual sources). Consequently, as the following diagram shows Protocol Buffers (Protobuf) is a method of serializing structured data. One of selling points of Protobuf was backward compatibility, i. Microservices mean we have to roll changes and updates constantly and so we need interfaces that can adapt and stay forward and backwards compatible, and protobufs are very good for this. 1 Aug 2019 Take the next step in microservices by using gRPC with . int32, uint32, int64, uint64, and bool are all compatible – this means you can change a field from one of these types to another without breaking forwards- or backwards-compatibility. Unfortunately, none of the gRPC implementations allow someone to take advantage of HTTP/2's backwards compatibility advantage to let us serve HTTP/1. rb extconf. Select titles are Xbox One X Enhanced, leveraging the additional power of the console for higher resolution, improved texture filtering, and expanded color detail. A lack of backwards compatibility might at first glance seem to be disruptive. 4 Jun 2018 gRPC itself is influenced by Stubby, an earlier RPC framework used by Protobuf ensures backward compatibility and offers validations and  21 Dec 2018 The plugins built with the PDK will be compatible with Kong It is semantically versioned which helps in maintaining backward compatibility. The API follows semantic versioning - any breaking, backwards incompatible change will be made while increasing the major version. Building. sint32 and sint64 are compatible with each other but are not compatible with the other integer types. By leveraging the protocol buffers backwards and forwards compatibility, the question of “Do I need to add this field or not?” or “What does this field accept?” stopped coming up. Protobufs are simply much faster and more efficient than things like JSON. google. The configuration files are JSON formatted, making them easily readable and editable by both humans and computers. We provide precompiled client stubs for Java. software engineering paradigms, such as backwards compatibility. 1 server, this is a bug. by adding new fields, in a manner that does not break backwards compatibility. Since the release of Xbox One Backward Compatibility with the New Xbox One Experience it has been one of the most popular features included in the update. • Can be cleartext or SSL-encrypted • A gRPC call is implemented as an HTTP POST request • Uses compact “protocol buffers” to exchange data between client and server • Protocol buffers are implemented in C++ as a class • Support added in NGINX 1. More details on gRPC 1. h in their source tree and modify as necessary. In the fifteenth episode of this podcast, your hosts Francesc and Mark interview Varun Talwar. There’s no caching because even if the client downloads data, the operation is POST. 13. We previously had many issues related to versioning that we wanted to fix. Existing code should not require modification to use a DI library. A small amount of configuration in your service to attach HTTP gRPC-Web is a cutting-edge spec that enables invoking gRPC services from modern browsers. KeyManagerFactory: PKIX: A factory for X509ExtendedKeyManager instances that manage X. The github repo also contains release archives that you may download. Note about backwards compatibility: In order for the feature to work correctly in presence of log truncations all log replicas need to be updated. Providing extensive backwards compatibility isn’t free; every new version is more code to understand and maintain. That’s an impressive install base, but if Sony releases a brand new console without backwards compatibility, they would essentially starting from scratch. typically interfaces can be designed to be backwards compatible. So if you have a communications protocol that uses protocol buffers as its data format, you can extend your protocol without having to worry about breaking existing code. 4 connecting to a 1. 23 Aug 2016 gRPC: a true internet-scale RPC framework is now 1. chromium / external / / external / gRPC allows a developer to generate interfaces for the various services. apache_beam. 'grpc_alpn%': 'true', # Indicates that the library should be built with gcov. Does not work with HTTP/1. Today, the gRPC project has reached a significant milestone with its 1. Aspera wallets will provide the regular HTTP and P2P API for backwards compatibility with both BRS wallets and user space applications relying on this API. (We still recommend Protobuf though due to strong backwards compatibility, type checking, and performance it gives you. You can configure new versions to be backward compatible, or the old ones to be  27 Aug 2016 There are multiple protocol buffer and protobuf-related software packages They are backward compatible with older versions of _pb2. Before reading this document, you should have familiarity with the concepts of schemata and protocols, as well as the various primitive and complex types available in Avro. The programmer can drop cmp. Package runtime contains runtime helper functions used by servers which protoc-gen-grpc-gateway generates. ‣ Added support for “stateful” models and backends that require multiple inference requests be routed to the same model instance/batch slot. Straightforward backwards compatibility with both OpenTracing and OpenCensus (via software bridges) Minimizing the time where OpenTelemetry, OpenTracing, and OpenCensus are being co-developed: we plan to put OpenTracing and OpenCensus into “readonly mode” before the end of 2019. You may find yourself going through several phases of evolution: Clone via HTTPS Clone with Git or checkout with SVN using the repository’s web address. grpc backwards compatibility

l7, ns, 9v, pf, hc, ix, tx, ec, fa, 1s, gj, ur, sg, xw, ih, h2, 2d, e5, tu, kj, z2, p9, ww, 8t, mq, 4o, jb, vp, gs, wb, 2e,